Expert insight by: Brad Fishbein, Licensed Mold Assessor
Updated April 7, 2025
Black mold and mildew may look alike at first glance, but don’t be fooled — they’re two different fungi with very different risks. Knowing which one you’re dealing with is key, because how you clean and prevent them is completely different.
In this guide, you’ll learn the key differences between black mold vs. mildew, how to tell them apart, how to clean them safely, and when it’s time to call in a pro.
Black mold, scientifically known as Stachybotrys chartarum, is a type of toxic mold that thrives in dark, damp environments. Think of basements, attics, bathrooms — any place with chronic moisture and organic material like wood or drywall.
It appears black or dark green and can look slimy or like someone scribbled with a wax crayon. This mold doesn’t just sit on the surface — it grows deep into porous materials and can be hard to remove safely.
Learn more: What is black mold and why is it dangerous?
Mildew is a surface-level fungus that often shows up in humid rooms like bathrooms and kitchens. It typically appears as a white or gray powdery film on tile, grout, or windowsills.
Unlike mold, mildew doesn’t penetrate materials deeply and is easier to clean with common household cleaners. It’s more of a nuisance than a health hazard — but that doesn’t mean it should be ignored.
Feature | Black Mold | Mildew |
---|---|---|
Color | Black or dark green | White, gray, or light yellow |
Texture | Slimy or fuzzy | Powdery or fluffy |
Location | Inside walls, ceilings, crawlspaces | On surfaces like tile, windowsills |
Depth | Penetrates porous materials | Stays on the surface |
Health Risk | Can produce mycotoxins (toxic) | Mild irritant |
Odor | Strong, musty, wet-earth smell | Mild musty odor |
Both mold and mildew need moisture, warmth, and organic material to grow. But their growth behaviors are different.
📸 Example:
Black mold can produce mycotoxins that may cause:
Some people develop mold allergies with severe symptoms, especially if they’re exposed over time.
⚠️ Prolonged exposure to black mold has been linked to neurological symptoms in extreme cases.
Mildew doesn't release mycotoxins, but it can still:
Mildew is annoying — but black mold is dangerous.
If the affected area is:
EPA says DIY is only safe under 10 sq. ft. — anything larger should be professionally treated.
Source: EPA Mold Cleanup Guide
Method | Best For | Notes |
---|---|---|
Vinegar | Mildew on hard surfaces | Natural, effective, non-toxic |
Borax | Mold on walls | Inhibits regrowth |
Mold cleaner | Showers, grout | Always follow label directions |
Bleach (sparingly) | Tile, grout | Avoid on porous surfaces (can worsen issue) |
Dead mold can still be harmful. Mold spores become airborne when dry and can spread fast. Always clean with PPE and address the source of moisture or it will come back.
🧠 Reminder: If it’s on drywall or insulation — it must be removed, not just cleaned.
👃 If your home smells musty, there’s a good chance mold is hiding behind the walls or under the floorboards.
Check out our guide to the Top 5 Air Purifiers for Mold
Both mold and mildew are fungi — but they’re not equally dangerous.
Fungi | Risk Level | Removal Difficulty |
---|---|---|
Mildew | Low | Easy (DIY) |
Black Mold | High | Difficult (Professional) |
If it’s black, slimy, growing on drywall or wood — call a pro.
If it’s white and powdery on tile — you may be able to handle it safely.
Mold penetrates surfaces and can cause health problems, while mildew grows on surfaces and is usually less harmful.
Mold is often black or green and slimy. Mildew is white or gray and powdery. Mold has a stronger odor and is more invasive.
Yes, black mold (Stachybotrys chartarum) produces mycotoxins that can cause respiratory and neurological symptoms with long-term exposure.
Yes. Mildew is usually safe to clean with vinegar or mold cleaners. Just make sure to ventilate the area and dry it completely afterward.
If the moldy area is larger than 10 square feet, or it's growing inside walls or your HVAC system, the EPA recommends hiring a licensed mold remediation expert.
If you think you have black mold — don’t guess.
👉 Start with a professional mold inspection to identify the species and determine if you need remediation.
The sooner you act, the safer your home (and health) will be.
Meet the author: Brad Fishbein is an ACAC council-certified Microbial Investigator. In the fall of 2012, he became a Licensed Mold Assessor in the State of Florida through the Department of Business & Professional Regulation. Brad has helped homeowners with over 5,000 successfully completed Mold Inspections since 2009.